The forbidden question. If you ask, you should pay

For Heaven’s sake…

As a photo enthusiast and long time now amateur user, I spend a lot of (read, way too much) time on internet photography dedicated boards and fora. After over 11 years of forum interaction, I’m still amazed, and now thoroughly annoyed, by the same question coming over, over, and over again. I call it “the forbidden” question. Frankly, I think folks should get a fine for asking !

Venise2013-81Fuji X10

So, the idiotic, forbidden question goes like this : between X and Y camera, which one takes the best pictures? (remember, next time you dare ask, I sue you). Dumb, heh ? Well, people keep on asking all the time. Duh. This annoys me to no end. SURE, the question might be relevant to *total* newcomers with NO idea or experience whatsoever about cameras and photography, but frankly, once you’ve reached a normal/average level of technical proficiency, and unless you tackle a very specific field of expertise (fast sports come to mind), in the same price range camera X is not gonna do much better over camera Y. 99% of the time, if a given user cannot get satisfying results with one, he’s not gonna do any better with the other.


The amount of “pixel peeping” and hair splitting, not to mention flame wars between loyal fans of different brands is mind boggling in the photo community. So I’ll tell it to you like it is. If you’ve had issues in the past getting the photos you want, and that despite trying a couple of cameras, including something above a basic “point&shoot”, compact model, then you may be better inspired trying to refine your photographic skills, rather than pulling your hair out over x vs. y…

X-E1:01The much desired XE-1. After trying it in the flesh it leaves me cold. Others make Art with it !

I’ll say it again I’ve shot Fuji, Minolta, Olympus, Nikon, Canon, Pentax, Panasonic and now Sony, oh, and lately Samsung (in that particular order, with a lot of going back and forth, buying, selling, re-buying the same thing again, etc), from entry model to pro grade stuff, and absolutely everything in between (cameras manufacturers really live off folks like me). I haven’t found a single brand of camera that couldn’t take decent pictures, and the limiting, or enpowering, factor has *always* been me. Sure, some particular models resonated deeper and better with me (Canon 1DmkII, Nikon D700, Panasonic GX-1, Sony NEX 7, etc) while others left me cold or were donwright disappointing (Canon 40D, Nikon D200, Olympus m4/3 bodies, Samsung NX200…) but I could have taken pictures with ANY of them, if I had to.

ColtJan13-28From my current favorite, Sony NEX 7

One very interesting factor one should pay attention to though, are personal preferences. Make a list of must-have features ; in my case, APS-C or FF sized sensor (which eliminates m4/3 and “large sensor” compacts), Rangefinder for factor, built-in electronic viewfinder, real time live view (exposure feeback on LCD screen or in EVF), bottom hinged tilt screen (*not* articulated to the side), direct access to exposure compensation, easily accessed White Balance settings. Just to name a few. Things I absolutely do NOT need, and don’t give a damn about : any sort of HDR feature, bracketing, time lapse, mobile phone like “applications”, in body stabilization, and a few more.


So do what you need to find the right camera according to your needs, but rest assured that your skill level, just like mine, is most likely to remain the sticking point, whatever gear you buy ๐Ÿ˜‰


About marla2008

Shutterbug. Shallow DOF nut. Mother of Child. Student of the Horse.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to The forbidden question. If you ask, you should pay

  1. Damn, I know you’re right, but I LIKE buying cameras under the pretense that A,B or C might make me better…..but I do pay for the privilege. Am I forgiven?? ๐Ÿ˜€

    • marla2008 says:

      No you don’t. You unashamedly buy new cameras because, just like me, you like it ! I, for one, never thought any of them would ever make me a better photographer. Although ultimately, and a few dozen units later, they did.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s